Beth El Community Profile
Ginny Granger, CBE Trustee
As told to Susan Armstrong
As I enter Ginny’s lovely home on a high hill, just east of town, I quickly surmise that I am visiting a well traveled lady. Beautiful hand carved, antique Asian pieces of furniture are eclectically interspersed with newer styles. Oh, did I mention the dead wooden horse on the porch with no head? I’ll leave it at that.
The table was laid out with fresh avocados stuffed with tasty salmon salad and an excellent olive tapenade on toast points. And then came the French rosé. I was in heaven. I won’t even attempt to describe the view. Here it is:
Ginny grew up in Magaliesburg, a village at the base of the Magaliesburg Mountains in South Africa. Her father owned a General Dealer store that sold everything from “coffins to buttons,” as she put it. Men would ride up on carts pulled by donkeys to purchase their stockpile for the month.” The houses had no electricity and we collected rain water in a huge tank on the side of the house. We had a cow to give us milk and chickens that gave us eggs and a Sunday roast. I had a horse that I would ride to see the circus when it came to town once a year. There was a railroad station at which the daily train to Zimbabwe would stop. The big city of Johannesburg was a two hour drive away. I grew up with no movies, no TV and no friends!”
At the tender age of five, Ginny was sent south to Notre Dame Convent School. It was a boarding school and she only returned home on school holidays. She used to tell people she was adopted because she felt such a separation from her parents. She was raised a Catholic, but soon began calling herself a “recovering Catholic.’ After she fully understood some of the issues within the Catholic Church, she called herself a “fully recovered Catholic.” Many years later, she studied with Rabbi Josh Boettiger at Congregation Beth El and converted to Judaism, the religion she felt she was always meant to be.
Following her high school graduation, she entered the Durban College of Technology to study radiography, on the east coast of South Africa. She received her degree and soon found that taking x-rays of peoples’ bodies was not her cup of tea. Fortunately, she met her first husband just at the time she was trying to figure out what to do next. The couple moved to Zimbabwe where they ran a tobacco farm, but because of gorilla warfare, they had to flee to the family sugar farm in Kwa Zulu Natal, South Africa. She now believes that both products, tobacco and sugar, should be banned. Together they raised three very successful children and the couple parted ways after 19 years of marriage.
Once again, she found herself at loose ends when in waltzed handsome Clifford Granger who danced her off her feet. He was an American (went to Williams College) who was born in Argentina. He worked for an international food corporation, so after their marriage her world travels truly began. First they lived in Hong Kong and then were transferred to Bangkok, where Ginny studied gemology at the Asian Institute of Gemological Science and lectured there on the subject of gemstones. They then moved on to Singapore where Ginny imported Copper Craft jewelry and other items from South Africa. Before retiring to the US, they had one more stint in Hong Kong.
That was 20 years ago. They settled in Williamstown, as Clifford had such fond memories of his time there at Williams. Throughout their retirement, Ginny kept very busy writing jewelry appraisals, entertaining friends, and taking part in the plays at the Williamstown Theatre Festival
with talking and dancing parts. All went well until Clifford began to have a series of strokes, which eventually ended his life in 2007. She describes him as “the finest human being I ever met.” Surely, his memory is her blessing.
Growing up Jewish in New Jersey
by Miriam Goodman Silver
I always knew I was Jewish. I cannot remember not knowing. I just was. It was not a case of me being proud. I did not go around saying I am proud to be a Jew. I just was, just like I was a girl. I never thought about being anything else. My grandparents were Jewish, my parents were Jewish and all my aunts and uncles and cousins were Jewish. I was not ashamed either. I never hid the fact that we were Jewish. But, sometimes I was uncomfortable being Jewish. Most of the kids on my block, or in my school, or in the town of Highland Park, New Jersey where I grew up, were NOT Jewish, and I was always conscious of these differences between me and most of the other children.
First of all, I did not go to school on Yom Tov, no matter what the Jewish holiday was. Mostly we joined my grandparents who lived in another town about 18 miles away that also did not have a Jewish population. We all went to services on the High Holy Days, Sukkot, Passover and Shavuous. My grandfather built the synagogue in his town and he was its first president. On Friday nights, we all gathered at his house where Bubba had baked little Challahs for the grandchildren and made tzimmis, kugel, chicken, chicken soup and compote for the Sabbath meal for all the adult children and their families. Even on minor Jewish holidays, I still stayed home or went to our local little Conservative temple.
Another difference was that I also went to Jewish school run by the Workman’s Circle or Arbeiter Ring on Mondays, Wednesdays and Fridays after public school. My parents sent me to learn to speak and read and write Yiddish. They wanted me to learn to be literate in Yiddish so that I could communicate with my grandparents.
I had to walk at least five miles across the bridge over the Raritan River to the town of New Brunswick to get there. This was a special place that taught children about the Yiddish language and culture. It introduced us to Yiddish songs, poetry and literature, as well as their writers. Everything was taught in Yiddish. I had the most wonderful teachers and I loved the way they taught. They were my role models, the only Jewish teachers I knew. But, I trace my love of teaching to my Jewish school teachers, and knew that I wanted to become a teacher because of the impact they had on me.
I started Jewish School at age five and continued until I graduated from Mitl Schule, comparable to Jewish High school. My Zaida always asked me to read Das Bintl Brief from the Yiddish newspaper so he could show me off when I visited him and his cronies in Atlantic City, where he vacationed. I was also the only grandchild who could speak Yiddish fluently, so I could converse with my grandmothers on both sides who never learned to speak English.
Going to Jewish School after school three times a week certainly set me apart from the other kids in school. I could not join the Brownies or the Girl Scouts, or even socialize with friends that much since I was always going off to another school. And so the Americanization process for me was delayed. By that I mean, all the social graces and skills my gentile counterparts picked up at these groups or in their socializing – like making canapés, making small talk, learning how to dress or walk or talk with soft voices and without flailing hands; when to say thank you or no thank you; how to depart from a party, how to be gracious and courteous; how to take a compliment and how to give one in return. All these social skills eluded me and some still do.
Playing in the neighborhood with my gentile friends also made me aware that I was different. They never invited me to stay over in their houses nor did I invite them to mine. Many of the kids with whom I went to school had parents who were on the faculty of Rutgers University or New Jersey College for Women across the river from Highland Park. Their parents were Americans who were educated, except for Mr. Orzini, the barber, who
was my neighbor.
My parents were immigrants, both coming from Russia, but only my dad was educated. He went to gymnasium (equal to two years of college) in Kishenev. When he arrived here at age 21, he enrolled in night school. He was literate in Russian, Rumanian, Yiddish and English. He worked in my grandfather’s factory in South River, NJ, where 100 women sat at sewing machines making women’s blouses. He was the foreman during my early growing up years, but he eventually bought the factory from my grandfather. It was then that he became the boss and I the boss’s daughter.
My mom was a functional illiterate. That is, she could barely read in any language, she spelled phonetically and spoke with a Yiddish accent. My grandfather had sent for his family after being in this country for seven years working to amass a fortune. He bought several factories and hired hundreds of Polish and Russian immigrants to work for him in the small town of South River. He
bought the mayor’s house and sent for his wife and six children, my mother being the middle child. They traveled upper class and he met them in New York with a chauffeur driven Studebaker.
Mom was 16 when she arrived, a zesty, beautiful young woman who never shied away from entering the world of America and she just loved life. She had a beautiful voice and always had a song on her lips and a smile on her face. She was a great baker and sang while she rolled out the dough for strudel or knishes. The dough has to be so thin that you could see through it. As she tossed the dough up in the air, I remember her saying, “It has to be as thin as ‘tzigair papeer’ (cigar paper). I loved watching her work with her rolling pin or meat grinder. But she never let me help.”Just go away and play,” she said, so I did. I never learned to cook or bake. She was in total control of the kitchen.
When she died at the age of 70, the rabbi, in delivering the eulogy, mainly cited how delicious Mamma’s strudel and knishes were and how generous she was in sharing them with the community. At the time I was dismayed to think that that was my mother’s chief legacy…and in my arrogance, I vowed that it would never be mine for sure! But today, with a bit more acquired wisdom, as I lovingly bake her” lokshen krugel,” I realize that was a symbol of her generosity, her caring for others and the gift of herself that she gave to all she loved.
Our foods were different from the other kids in school. They ate white bread with peanut butter and jelly. Mom would give me challah with cream cheese or sometimes even halvah. We ate sour cream and bananas, pot cheese and when we were lucky, we had lox.
I even looked and dressed differently. My mom made all my clothes from left over material from my dad’s factory. There was always a Singer sewing machine in our house just like the ones in my Dad’s factory. She was always pinning patterns on the table- fitting me with half sewn garments and making me chew thread while she sewed on the collars of the dress she was finishing for me. They always seemed to be sewn on crooked. I hated my home grown dresses. They were usually rayon prints and ugly colors. I yearned for the beige cashmere cardigan sets my schoolmates wore with a little string of pearls. They wore cotton dirndl skirts or broomstick skirts that you would wash and wrap on brooms to dry.
My hair was different from my classmates. It was long and never cut. Mom braided my hair each morning and threaded the braids with binding we had on spools from the factory. She then tied the ends of the binding in a bow or knot. By four o’clock each day, the braids invariably escaped from the “ribbons” and my hair was dangling at the ends looking quite scraggly. When my dad would pick me up at six o’clock, after Jewish School on his way home from work, he often commented that I looked like “machshiafa,” Yiddish for gypsy. I longed for short straight hair with bangs and barrettes like the other girls in school. Finally, when I was 12, I summed up the courage to make an appointment with my neighbor, a barber, who gave me a “feather cut.” My dad did not talk to me for a week!
Another time of anxiety came during the month of December. Chanukah in our house was the ritual that never wavered. Our dad gave us each a silver dollar the first night of Chanukah after we lit the candles – and that was that. Period. Later it was a gold five dollar piece when times were better, but further on in the month when Christmas was over, my friends’ parents would ask me if Santa had been good to me. I never had the poise to let them know how inappropriate that question was.
It was only in school when teachers had us trace out Xmas wreaths and cut out Santa Claus that I was in pain. I was left handed and could not cut very well under any circumstances. Besides, no one was sensitive to how alien these symbols were for me, so I just went along to get along. The same was true in later years, when I loved to sing in the choir. At Christmas, I had to sing all the hymns and Christian songs that were so unfamiliar. It grieved my dad when he came to an assembly program one time and saw me utter the words that were never ever mentioned in our home.
As we entered our teen years, I was never again invited to join my gentile friends in anything social – just in school activities. I learned later that many attended a social dancing class on Saturdays at a Miss somebody or other’s salon, where they learned social graces of how to behave at social gatherings and how to dance with a partner correctly. I never did learn that skill!!
However, I learned other skills as president of a newly formed Young Judea group in New Brunswick, since all my family were Zionists. My grandmother, mother and all my aunts were life members of Hadassah and it was a natural thing for me to do. At the age of 12, I also had a memorable two week summer stint at the Jewish Camp sponsored by the Workmen’s Circle called Kinder Ring. It was there in the Catskills that I starred in a Yiddish play produced by a 2nd Avenue Jewish Theater professional. It was a high for me! After that experience, I went with my parents to the Yiddish theater in New York City frequently to see Maurice Schwartz and Molly Picon. We ate at Jewish restaurants like Rappaport's and Ratner's in downtown Manhattan. But, once my dad took me uptown to Rossoff’s, a more sophisticated restaurant, to show me how to order in the event I ever got to go out on a date to a place like that in the future. I was so thrilled. I felt so grown up and still remember that day with joy.
When my classmates asked me where I had gone over the weekend, I did not think they would ever have heard of these places, and so I told them the name of a restaurant I had read on the back of the envelope in which our tickets had come. It said Sardi’s. Whether it was shame or discomfort, I do not know, but our worlds were now so separate and apart, that I felt like I was an outsider looking in to their alien society.
Back in the small high school of less than 200 in our graduating class in Highland Park, I became the editor-in- chief of our high school paper, the president of the dramatic club and the director of our senior play. And, in our year book, there is my picture as the “Girl Voted the Most Likely to Succeed.”
However, I was not accepted into the Women’s College in New Brunswick. It was the only place my parents could afford, or would let me go since it was in our home town and I could commute. We were told that the quota for Jewish girls was filled and I was placed on a waiting list. My dad was devastated. It was his dream for his daughter to have a college education, at the school he wanted, but could not have. He had driven past the college for 20 years on his way to and from work.
By this time, he had made many influential friends in town and he contacted the one Jewish man who was on the Board of Trustees of the College. After Dad made a major contribution to the school, the quota was expanded to include me! This was my final experience of being Jewish in Highland Park and New Brunswick, NJ.
A few years later, when I became a professor at a New Jersey State College in another small town called Montclair, I once again felt as though I was back in Highland Park. I was among the few Jewish faculty members. And once again, I simply went about being Jewish because that is what I am. But this time, there was no longer any discomfort. This time there was a State of Israel in the world. That fact changed the way I felt about myself. Today, I am very comfortable as a Jewish woman in Bennington, even though it feels so similar to that small town in New Jersey where I grew up. The creation of a Jewish state has made the difference for me and thousands of other Jewish people growing up in the Diaspora. My children and my children’s children have no idea the difference it has made for them as they have grown up.
February 1, 2002
Beth El Community Profile
Alice and Alan Greenspan, aka Al and Al
As told to Susan Armstrong
Alice and Al both grew up in Perth Amboy, NJ, around the corner from one another. Al is four years her senior. When they were young, the depression was in full force, but both considered themselves privileged because they had comfortable lifestyles, despite all the want and need throughout the country. Their families belonged to the same Conservative temple – Beth Mordechai. Alice’s father was Treasurer of the board, “forever.” Because bat mitzvahs were rare at that time, Alice was confirmed. Al became a bat mitzvah and was tutored in Hebrew by the Cantor Efros, a well known composer of liturgical music.
Alice had a beautiful sister, seven years her senior, named Jacquie. Alan was quick to tell me that she looked like Ava Gardner. On Friday nights she would sit on the front porch and the boys would line up to talk to her. Mischievous Alice sat up in a second floor window throwing notes out to the boys. Alice said, “I had to grow up in the shadow of my beautiful sister.”
When asked if anything had ever happened in their lives that changed everything, Alice immediately told about a giant explosion that occurred on two barges in the Raritan River, just two blocks from her family’s home. She was talking on the phone on the second floor when suddenly the explosion blew out all the windows in the entire house, including the room where she was standing. She was covered in blood and ran downstairs to see if everyone was okay. Her mother and father had both escaped injury. She grabbed her new spring coat and they all ran outside. Having not worn shoes, she ended up with bleeding feet as well. The city was put under Martial Law when it was discovered that the barges that had collided were smuggling arms to Pakistan. First aid stations were set up and Alice was patched back together.
Both Alan and Alice attended Jewish summer camps, Alice in Monterey, MA and Al at Camp Kiowa in Honesdale, PA. They each had dogs in their families and remain dog lovers to this day. They attended local Perth Amboy schools until Al was sent away to a private school, as his mother wanted to shield him from his father’s illness. He attended the George School in Newtown, PA, founded by Quakers. Two of his classmates were Stephen Sondheim and Blythe Danner. Al tells the story that Oscar Hammerstein’s son, Jimmy, was also a student there. Stephen had written some music for a class play, and Oscar Hammerstein himself just happened to be in the audience. And so began Sondheim’s brilliant musical career. The Greenspans attended Sondheim’s play, "Applause," on Broadway years later, and Stephen was in the audience. Al went over to say hello and was greeted by name immediately. It was impressive to be remembered after all those years.
In his teen years, Alan sported a pompadour hair style a la Elvis. Walking by Alice’s house one day, he saw her outside. Al flipped her a nickel and said, “Call me when you’re 16.” What a move! He went off to Washington University, then on to graduate school at Northwestern, where he earned a degree in Macroeconomics. Next Al served in the 101st Airborne Division and fought in North Korea. After putting up with freezing conditions in that country, he was sent to Oklahoma City, where he roasted. There Al taught combat intelligence – how to interrogate prisoners. By this time, both he and Alice had married other people and each had three girls of their own.
Al had a sterling career on Wall Street with Rothchild & Co., Oppenheimer & Co. and was a Senior Vice President at Morgan Stanley. For years he oversaw the NYC Pension Fund, where he was tasked with foreseeing the economic future. Alice owned a successful interior design company, all the while raising her girls. In fact, she has an assignment right now to design the interior of a home in Burlington. Her creativity never stops.
They had not seen each other for twenty one years, but their parents had their fingers crossed that the two would re-connect, because each was getting a divorce. As soon as they saw each another, Al said, “We know each other well. Let’s get married.” But Alice gave him a hard time. She resisted until they finally wed eleven months later. Together they raised their daughters and shared their common interest in mountain climbing. They even traveled to New Zealand, where they scaled some of mountains in the Southern Alps and hiked the Greenstone Track out of Queensland.
It has now been forty seven years that Alice and Alan have been married. Their families have melded together – all six girls. They have thirteen grandchildren and three great grandchildren. They have remained happily together for over half of their lives.
They moved permanently to Wilmington, VT in 2003, after having spent years coming up to to Mt. Snow from New Jersey with their family to ski. In 1999 they began their association with Congregation Beth El. Al volunteered to manage the CBE investment funds over ten years ago and has done a stellar job. Alice is a trustee on the Board of Directors. We are indeed fortunate that the Greenspans continue to enrich our congregation.
Beth El Community Profile
Alvin and Roberta Michaels – A Love Story
As told to Susan Armstrong
Al and Roberta grew up in Flatbush, Brooklyn, NY. Their families didn’t live very far from each other. The both attended
Midwood High School where they began to notice one another. They went out on a few dates, went out on a few dates
with others and finally realized they were right for each other. That was 74 years ago and they are still going strong.
Neither of their families was extremely religious, but both Al and Roberta were proud of their Jewish heritage and history.
Ethics, good morals and doing the right thing were themes in both households. Roberta’s father, who was an attorney,
would point out “bad actors” when he met one.
After graduation, Al went to the Brooklyn College of Pharmacy, (like father like son) and Roberta went to Adelphi
University to study teaching, (like mother like daughter). When Al graduated from pharmacy school, he asked Roberta
to marry him. Roberta’s father said, “Not until you pass the board and become licensed, Al” And, so they waited a little
longer. When they finally did get married, it was at the Brooklyn Jewish Center. Rabbi Levinthal performed the ceremony,
just as he had done years earlier to marry Roberta’s parents.
Al was drafted into the Army in November after their wedding. It turns out that someone he knew switched their orders, so that he could stay in the states and Al would be sent overseas. Al figured out what had happened and reported it to the Inspector General. Al said, “If I have to go, that guy is coming with me.” Fortunately, Al ended up at Valley Forge Hospital in Pennsylvania and the other guy went overseas.
When the war was over, their lives began in earnest. Roberta became a teacher in Brooklyn and Al began his career as a pharmacist. He worked at the Harlem Hospital, the Brooklyn Hospital and opened his own business. Five years after their wedding, BonnieDara was born and eight years later, TammiRuth was born. Tammi had a learning disability, so Roberta stayed home for the next 10 years to give her the best possible start. After that, Roberta became the principal of a private school, Winston Preparatory, for special needs students in NYC - once more, always being there for TammiRuth.
They loved to travel and were fortunate enough to visit France, Italy, England, Egypt, Spain, Israel and Morocco. Al told a story about their visit to Morocco. Tammi was small in stature and walked slowly. They took a tour out to a beach with a Moroccan guide. He thought Tammi was adorable and took her hand to lead her to the beach, which made her feel very special. On the way back, the Arab called her a “mini” and said in jest, “I’ll give you two camels for her.” They all got a good laugh from that.
When Roberta was growing up, her family spent many summers at the Lake St. Catherine Inn, and Al and Roberta wanted to share that experience with their girls, as well. In 1995, after years of wonderful visits to Vermont, they bought a condominium in Manchester. By the year 2,000, they moved to Vermont permanently. Roberta had taken two years of training to become a docent to lead children through the Metropolitan Museum of Art. This was an enlightening experience for her, so she traveled back to the city for two years, several times a month to continue in this role. Al served on the Manchester Village Board for five very satisfying years, and on the Board of Trustees of Equinox on the Battenkill for ten years.
Their daughter, BonnieDara, who is the curator of the Yeshiva Museum, lives in lower Manhattan with her husband Dr. Michael Tunik and their daughter Melissa.
I sat outside with them on their lovely deck surrounded by trees, watching the song birds at their feeders and the Humming birds darting back and forth. They are so loving and solicitous towards one another and clearly, still in love.